Thinking about getting rid of that old bathtub and putting in a sleek, modern shower? You’re not alone. More and more homeowners are opting to convert their tubs to showers, and it’s not just about looks.
Whether you’re navigating a tight bathroom space, accommodating mobility needs, or simply trying to modernize your home, this decision can bring both value and convenience. But is it the right move for you?
Let’s dive into the pros and cons of converting a tub to a shower, with a local lens on the things that matter most—like real estate trends, water usage, space constraints, and even climate considerations.
Why This Decision Matters More Than You Think
As real estate prices rise and older homes often come with smaller bathrooms, optimizing your space is no longer just a design decision—it’s a lifestyle enhancement.
Additionally, with growing awareness around water conservation, particularly in drought-prone areas, showers are emerging as the more sustainable and practical choice.
That said, a tub-to-shower conversion isn’t always the obvious winner. Local regulations, resale value, and your family’s needs all play into the decision.
Let’s unpack the benefits and the trade-offs so you can make the right call for your home.
The Pros of Converting a Tub to a Shower
1. Better Use of Space
Showers take up less room than a full bathtub, especially walk-in or corner units. If you’re dealing with a tight bathroom, converting to a shower can make the space feel bigger and more functional.
2. Modern Appeal
Let’s be honest—most standard tubs don’t scream luxury. A walk-in shower with sleek glass doors and modern tile instantly elevates your bathroom. For homeowners, where modern aesthetics can increase buyer interest, that’s a big plus.
3. Improved Accessibility
If someone in your household is aging or has mobility issues, a low-threshold or curbless shower is far safer than stepping over a high tub wall. In fact, local building codes may even encourage these designs for universal access.
4. Water Efficiency
In areas where water conservation is key, switching to a shower can help lower your water bill. The average bath uses 35-50 gallons of water, while a 10-minute shower with a low-flow showerhead uses as little as 20 gallons.
5. Faster Morning Routines
No one has time to fill a tub every morning. Showers are just more practical, especially for busy families.
The Cons of Converting a Tub to a Shower
1. Resale Concerns
If your home has only one full bathroom and you remove the bathtub, it could hurt your resale value. Many families with young kids see bathtubs as essential.
2. Permit and Plumbing Costs
Depending on your city, you might need a permit to change plumbing fixtures or adjust drainage. Permits can cost between $100 and $500, and inspections may be required.
3. Loss of Versatility
A bath is not just for kids. For many, it’s a stress-reducing ritual. Replacing it with a shower means giving that up—unless you’re lucky enough to have a second tub elsewhere in the home.
4. Potential Hidden Costs
If your existing tub hides water damage or outdated plumbing (not uncommon in older homes), your remodel might balloon in cost once the demo begins.
Should You Convert Your Tub to a Shower?
Ask yourself these key questions:
- Do I have another tub in the home?
- Will this improve everyday function or accessibility?
- How long do I plan to stay in this house?
- Is water conservation a priority for me?
- Am I upgrading for resale value or personal comfort?
If you’re leaning toward “yes” for most of these, then a conversion might make a lot of sense.
Local Regulations & Permits You Should Know About
Depending on your location, you’ll likely need a permit for any work that involves plumbing or structural changes. Bathroom remodeling projects may require:
- A residential building permit
- A plumbing permit (if you’re moving pipes)
- An inspection after the work is done
How Climate Plays a Role in Your Decision
You might not think climate matters in a bathroom remodel, but it does. In colder regions, some homeowners prefer a tub for soaking during winter. In warmer, more arid areas like [Region], showers are favored for their quick use and water-saving design.
Humidity is another factor. If your home is in a humid zone, make sure your new shower has proper ventilation and moisture-resistant materials to prevent mold.
Best Tub-to-Shower Conversion Materials & Options
When choosing the right shower style and material, consider:
- Acrylic shower kits – Affordable and quick to install.
- Tile showers – Customizable, stylish, but more labor-intensive.
- Glass doors vs. curtains – Glass gives a sleek look and keeps water in better.
- Curbless or low-threshold – Ideal for accessibility.
Best Tub-to-Shower Manufacturers to Consider
Choosing the right manufacturer ensures longevity and ease of installation. These brands consistently deliver quality and performance.
- Kohler – Known for elegant designs and their easy-to-install LuxStone shower walls.
- American Standard – Long-lasting materials and ADA-compliant designs for safety and comfort.
- DreamLine – Modern aesthetics with frameless and semi-frameless glass enclosures.
- Sterling (by Kohler) – Budget-friendly and practical, ideal for fast remodels.
FAQ: Tub-to-Shower Conversion Questions Homeowners Ask
Q: How much does it cost to convert a tub to a shower?
A: The average cost ranges from $3,000 to $8,000, depending on materials and labor.
Q: How long does a tub-to-shower conversion take?
A: Most standard conversions take 2–5 days, though custom tile work may take longer.
Q: Do I need a contractor or can I DIY it?
A: You can DIY some kits, but if plumbing is involved—or permits are required—a licensed contractor is your safest bet.
Q: Will it hurt my home’s resale value if I remove the only tub?
A: Possibly. If your home has just one bathroom, it’s often best to keep the tub.
Q: Can I make the new shower accessible?
A: Yes! Curbless entries, grab bars, and handheld showerheads are all excellent features for accessibility.
Final Thoughts: So, Should You Convert Your Tub?
If you’re planning to age in place, crave a modern look, or want to make the most of a small bathroom, converting a tub to a shower can be a smart move. But it’s not a one-size-fits-all decision. Consider your lifestyle, future plans, and how it fits into the broader needs of your home.
And remember, whether you’re just brainstorming or ready to take the plunge, we’re here to help you think it through.
Ready to Get Started?
If you’re serious about upgrading your bathroom and want to chat with someone who knows this industry inside and out, contact us at (443) 261-9582. We’d love to walk you through the possibilities and help you make the right call for your home.